Are Electric Cars the biggest con on the planet???

Are Electric Cars the biggest con on the planet???

Author
Discussion

silent ninja

824 posts

87 months

Yesterday (12:27)
quotequote all
SWoll said:
This is why we'll be dropping the do it all EV this year and moving to a 2 car setup. EV city car for everyday local stuff and an ICE for high days and holidays. Life's too short for charging stress when you're trying to have a fun weekend/week away and need petrol back in my life after 4 years of EV only.
Interesting. I think you've got the same car as me (BMW iX3). There is definitely more faff in electric and I really think they're too complicated right now, but the pay off is a super refined drive and cheaper bills. I've only had mine a week and am experiencing teething issues.

I'm going to Cornwall in July and the house we're staying in has an EV charger. So that pretty much means we will be fully gassed up everyday. More and more holiday homes are installing them, especially if they want to target the right customer.

Merc 450

855 posts

86 months

Yesterday (12:36)
quotequote all
Biggest con ever there can never be enough charging points for everyone, even if they changed the date to 2050. I for one will be changing my Mustang 5.0GT and my Range Rover late 2029 and I bet a lot of other people will too👍

SpeckledJim

30,439 posts

240 months

Yesterday (12:38)
quotequote all
Merc 450 said:
Biggest con ever there can never be enough charging points for everyone, even if they changed the date to 2050. I for one will be changing my Mustang 5.0GT and my Range Rover late 2029 and I bet a lot of other people will too??
Fess up, this is a huge guess, isn't it.


Merc 450

855 posts

86 months

Yesterday (12:43)
quotequote all
SpeckledJim said:
Fess up, this is a huge guess, isn't it.
No if say 200 people live in a 20 story block of flats how are you going to get the leads up to the top floors. The wiring would look like Thailand.
Also try getting your car charged north of Fort William and Inverness

Hill92

3,817 posts

177 months

Yesterday (12:51)
quotequote all
Merc 450 said:
No if say 200 people live in a 20 story block of flats how are you going to get the leads up to the top floors. The wiring would look like Thailand.
Also try getting your car charged north of Fort William and Inverness
How many 20 story blocks of flats have parking for 200 people? And why would all 200 need to charge at once? You don't need to provision all the parking spaces that currently exist with a charger.

Getting petrol north of Fort William and Inverness is no easy feat either. At least with EVs, local residents visitors can charge at home and start every day with full range instead of having to make 30 mile detours to the nearest petrol station.

SpeckledJim

30,439 posts

240 months

Yesterday (13:03)
quotequote all
Merc 450 said:
SpeckledJim said:
Fess up, this is a huge guess, isn't it.
No if say 200 people live in a 20 story block of flats how are you going to get the leads up to the top floors. The wiring would look like Thailand.
Gosh, you're right. They're going to have to think of another way other than a 20 storey May Pole of charging cables. But there can't be any other way! Check-mate! Aaargh.

Merc 450 said:
Also try getting your car charged north of Fort William and Inverness
Yup, peat-burning three-pin sockets are only just catching on in Scotland. They don't have any proper electricity.

You're across all the issues. I'm glad you've arrive to draw this hopeless thread to a close. We've been battling with these questions for ages, unable to bring ourselves to realise it was all for nought.

I'll put it down to misplaced optimism and go and sit in the sea.





98elise

24,020 posts

148 months

Yesterday (13:05)
quotequote all
Merc 450 said:
Biggest con ever there can never be enough charging points for everyone, even if they changed the date to 2050. I for one will be changing my Mustang 5.0GT and my Range Rover late 2029 and I bet a lot of other people will too??
Every electrical outlet is a charging point. What's your car to outlet ratio?

Wherever there is electicity you can add a charging point. Our local Aldi put over 20 chargers in overnight. I mean that literally, one day they weren't there the next they were.

98elise

24,020 posts

148 months

Yesterday (13:08)
quotequote all
Merc 450 said:
SpeckledJim said:
Fess up, this is a huge guess, isn't it.
No if say 200 people live in a 20 story block of flats how are you going to get the leads up to the top floors. The wiring would look like Thailand.
Also try getting your car charged north of Fort William and Inverness
Why do you need to charge from an extension lead? You aren't tied into your homes electricity supply.

Charge it where you park it, or pop into a fast charge station.

Maracus

4,001 posts

155 months

Yesterday (13:14)
quotequote all
Merc 450 said:
SpeckledJim said:
Fess up, this is a huge guess, isn't it.
No if say 200 people live in a 20 story block of flats how are you going to get the leads up to the top floors. The wiring would look like Thailand.
Also try getting your car charged north of Fort William and Inverness
I managed it last year up in the Isle Of Skye in July. Plenty of ChargePlace Scotland 50Kw chargepoints around. Met a couple from Holland in the Isle of Skye who were touring Scotland in their Model X. They had no complaints. Obviously an ICE car would be less hassle, but for the once in a blue moon I would travel up there it's no real problem.

GT9

4,310 posts

159 months

Yesterday (15:52)
quotequote all
Merc 450 said:
Biggest con ever there can never be enough charging points for everyone, even if they changed the date to 2050. I for one will be changing my Mustang 5.0GT and my Range Rover late 2029 and I bet a lot of other people will too??
Yeehah, you tell 'em Merc!

Bunch of nappy-wearing imbeciles driving jumped-up milk-floats...

Fastlane

947 posts

204 months

Yesterday (20:25)
quotequote all
GT9 said:
Yeehah, you tell 'em Merc!

Bunch of nappy-wearing imbeciles driving jumped-up milk-floats...
Reckon its tea time at the retirement home and he's nipped onto the shared computer...

Puzzles

688 posts

98 months

Yesterday (20:42)
quotequote all
I do think the gov should have installed far more chargers, I'm lucky that I have a drive but I do think a lot of cheap but slower chargers in council own car parks would have been a great idea and maybe energy companies could offer a cheap overnight rate which would help the people who live in flats etc.

Diderot

5,796 posts

179 months

Yesterday (23:28)
quotequote all
Puzzles said:
I do think the gov should have installed far more chargers, I'm lucky that I have a drive but I do think a lot of cheap but slower chargers in council own car parks would have been a great idea and maybe energy companies could offer a cheap overnight rate which would help the people who live in flats etc.
Like many energy companies do already? We're with Octopus Go ... 7.5p still.

DonkeyApple

48,965 posts

156 months

Puzzles said:
I do think the gov should have installed far more chargers, I'm lucky that I have a drive but I do think a lot of cheap but slower chargers in council own car parks would have been a great idea and maybe energy companies could offer a cheap overnight rate which would help the people who live in flats etc.
The government shouldn't be installing anything nor paying for anything. Such a mechanism is hugely wasteful of taxpayer money.

They should legislate where the chargers need to be, legislate how much commission they can charge for vending electricity and then place tax penalties on EV vendors and energy companies that are sufficient to steer private capital into building the national network.

One only needs to look at the state and cost of anything run or paid for by the govt to see why it would be clinically insane to rely on them to create a national network to keep lower paid workers sufficiently mobile.

They can't even keep public toilets clean and operational and we are suggesting they run our car refuelling network? Total madness.

And here is the other key aspect that keeps being overlooked:

The EV market today is not for those who cannot home charge.

The EV market today is all about those who can home charge, those who can capitalise on the tax incentives, those who have the income and wealth to absorb the inconveniences and gain from the advantages. And it is these consumers who will continue over the next two decades to create the market and infrastructure that others will be needing before they can easily switch in ten to twenty years.

There is no sanity in paying to install and maintain chargers for consumers ten years or more before they need them. That's the kind of loony spending that sees the provincial governments of the U.K. bankrupting themselves and their wards screwed. It's gesture politics at the expense of common sense and the bill is always paid by those they are aiming to dupe.

The majority of U.K. households with cars have the ability to home charge one way or another. These are the households that the market aims to switch over the next 10-20 years and it is their switching that will facilitate the wider network that permits the others to switch.

The uncomfortable reality is that like not everyone can just have a Ferrari, not everyone can have an EV bit they will be able to in the years to come but demanding they have one right now and that the world delivers them a charging network immediately is just a bit churlish.

whirlybird

Original Poster:

606 posts

174 months

All this talk of people living in flats and not having the ability to charge their EV's reminds me of J G Ballards Dystopian book and the film High-Rise.
If I recall the 'plebs' lived on the lower floors while the High & Mighty lived in isolated splendor on the top storey penthouse? Strikes me that this view of the future probably already exists, where the well healed can park & charge their Audi E-Tron Quattros/Lucid Airs/Bentley/Rimac Evera in underground splendor,while living the 'highlife', The Plebs having to smoke around in smelly old ICE cars as there is no way to charge a Leaf if you live in the Aylesbury Estate in Walworth.




Edited by whirlybird on Friday 24th March 10:02

Nomme de Plum

446 posts

3 months

whirlybird said:
All this talk of people living in flats and not having the ability to charge their EV's reminds me of J G Ballards Dystopian book and the film High-Rise.
If I recall the 'plebs' lived on the lower floors while the High & Mighty lived in isolated splendor on the top storey penthouse? Strikes me that this view of the future probably already exists, where the well healed can park & charge their Audi E-Tron Quattros/Lucid Airs/Bentley/Rimac Evera in underground splendor,while living the 'highlife', The Plebs having to smoke around in smelly old ICE cars as there is no way to charge a Leaf if you live in the Aylesbury Estate in Walworth.




Edited by whirlybird on Friday 24th March 10:02
It's a rather depressing lens you seem to see life through.

Surely the Aylesbury estate has very limited parking anyway so your comment re EV charging is somewhat irrelevant.

whirlybird

Original Poster:

606 posts

174 months

Nomme de Plum said:
whirlybird said:
All this talk of people living in flats and not having the ability to charge their EV's reminds me of J G Ballards Dystopian book and the film High-Rise.
If I recall the 'plebs' lived on the lower floors while the High & Mighty lived in isolated splendor on the top storey penthouse? Strikes me that this view of the future probably already exists, where the well healed can park & charge their Audi E-Tron Quattros/Lucid Airs/Bentley/Rimac Evera in underground splendor,while living the 'highlife', The Plebs having to smoke around in smelly old ICE cars as there is no way to charge a Leaf if you live in the Aylesbury Estate in Walworth.




Edited by whirlybird on Friday 24th March 10:02
It's a rather depressing lens you seem to see life through.

Surely the Aylesbury estate has very limited parking anyway so your comment re EV charging is somewhat irrelevant.
I think that you are taking my comments far too seriously, and that you should consider sometimes biggrin I will respond somewhat 'tongue in cheek'.
What I still find amusing is how serious and vocal some people are, and quite simply spend time responding to all and sundry posts, despite subject matter, its like they consider posting on PH as 'their full time job' !!! rolleyes

DonkeyApple

48,965 posts

156 months

I think folk living in awful high rise sink estates have become the new go to people to protect from evil oppression now the whole 'children mining cobalt' thing has worn off and had to accept that no one really cares how many children are consumed and abused to get their shiny new purchases delivered to their front door. wink

It's a bit like vegetarianism stopped having any disruptive impact so they had to roll our 'lactose intolerance' and when that was eventually ignored they had to leap on the vegan bandwagon and then the trans stuff.

People don't actually care. They just seek out proxy victims to manipulate and abuse to fit their own agenda.

For old geezers in houses with driveways and no actual need to ever travel anywhere that an EV couldn't easily do as they don't have to be anywhere at any time and have nice big pensions to pay the lease costs, it's become fashionable to pretend to care about the downtrodden as a means to exploit those people's situation to justify their own desires and beliefs.

Last week it was kids mining cobalt, this week it seems to be people without cars in 60s Council blocks. Next week it'll be the evil of EV use that forces people to push puffins are their arses or some such waffle about caring about something they have never once cared about their entire life.

Are these people quaffing their wife's left over HRT pills? wink

whirlybird

Original Poster:

606 posts

174 months

Nomme de Plum said:
It's a rather depressing lens you seem to see life through.

Surely the Aylesbury estate has very limited parking anyway so your comment re EV charging is somewhat irrelevant.
As an aside, I actually come from Aylesbury (Buckinghamshire) originally, ( but not the Aylesbury Estate in Walford )
but if you've ever been through Aylesbury in rush hour I can see why an estate was named after it. Once you've been there you never want to return !!!!

blueacid

397 posts

128 months

Merc 450 said:
No if say 200 people live in a 20 story block of flats how are you going to get the leads up to the top floors. The wiring would look like Thailand.
Also try getting your car charged north of Fort William and Inverness
Most high-rise buildings don't have many car parking spaces at all, full stop.
A building near to me in Manchester has 110 dwellings. 1 or 2 bed, so you've got perhaps some single people, some couples and some with 3+ folks in, depending on how awkwardly third-wheely some living situations might be.
So we can presume 150-odd people living there.

40 car parking spaces. But, all the meters are in a cupboard in the same car park, so it's not unthinkable to sort something out (perhaps with a keyswitch to prevent people charging off other folks power). OR the landlord could install a system with contactless payment. OR they can use the new MFG charging point which has 8 150kw-capable bays at it, just a 2 min drive away.